Technical Director at Mott MacDonald, Nick Carman has spent his career helping shape a greener built environment across Aotearoa and overseas. Starting out in structural engineering, he is dedicated to championing holistic sustainability, driving down embodied carbon and guiding project teams to balance resilience with smart environmental outcomes. A 2026 Green Star Champion, Nick is also passionate about passing on his hard-won knowledge to the wider industry.
Your career started as structural engineering on projects across Aotearoa and many other countries. How did reducing carbon then become such a massive focus for you?
I think I just followed the thread of ‘how can the project be better’ and that is where I ended up! Once I discovered that the Engineering Design disciplines could make a huge difference to the environmental outcomes of a project with GHG-emissions/Carbon impact introduced as a proxy-measure for that, I couldn’t help but try to optimise it.
Then a more fulsome range of indicators via an LCA builds on that further, and then thanks to Planetary Boundaries work we’ll hopefully soon have indicators for Biodiversity and BioGeoChem + Novel Entities Flows as well. It’s all very exciting, and it can enable Engineers and Building Designers/Specifiers to be proven Environmental super-heroes!
As Technical Director at Mott MacDonald, you champion holistic sustainability and project decision-making. What does that look like when you first sit down with a project team?
Yeah so first of all, one of the reasons I have enjoyed working in the Built Environment field here is that every project has unique features and opportunities - so I would encourage people to keep the thinking fresh and open at the start of each project. But within that, simple conversations at the start around project; scale, position on/in/above the site, timeline (design, construction, operation, ownership, legacy), ground + climatic conditions, budget(CapEx & OpEx) and procurement approach are going to set big parts of the Brief to a design team: and thus the outcomes.
So actually programming in a defined period to work that up between your lead design disciplines and the client-rep before locking in a fixed brief is I think always worth it.
We've got some pretty unique seismic requirements here. How do you balance making a commercial building safe and resilient while also trying to keep the carbon footprint of the materials to a minimum?
Well balance is the right word: once we are clearly achieving the minimum requirements for Time-Cost-Quality/Resilience-Carbon on a project it becomes about the Designers and the Client having direct conversations on which of these they want to (or can) go beyond-the-minimum on, informed by clear metrics on each. That means the project must Measure-Report-Improve-Repeat several times to find the answer to that.
In the case of the specific question here that would mean quantifying the seismic performance outcomes, the capex and opex outcomes, the procurement timeline implications, the operational carbon outcomes, and the predicted embodied carbon outcomes of the major design options to guide the decision on what to build. On a large project it will be a complex problem and must be respected and resourced as-such.
Looking at it from a structural lens, are we seeing enough new ideas with low-carbon materials like mass timber and green concrete to actually hit our industry targets?
I don’t think it is actually much about new materials, as we can already make big reductions in the embodied carbon associated with buildings if we follow the ‘what structural system(s) would be most suited to this span’ and then make sure we also challenge back on the reverse ‘what span is most suited to this system’ feedback to the rest of the project leadership.
If the Engineers are asked/forced to design a big transfer structure system instead of a continuous column, or to stetch a floor system beyond its efficient range, then guess what? It costs more money and more carbon.
But in the long-term, to continue the downward trajectory, some new materials will be useful: As one example, I’d like to see more R&D going into the opportunities and challenges of pozzolanic materials (including low-emissions drying) from NZ's vast volcanic deposits for the creation of local- lower-carbon concrete.
You were named a Green Star Champion this year recognising your massive contribution to sustainable building practices and your work in tackling carbon. What has been the most rewarding part of this journey for you?
The teaching/training opportunities I have had, to pass on hard-won lessons and knowledge to others, so that they can build on it, is something I’ve reflected on recently.
Doing that day-to-day in the office with colleagues but also for/with various Industry Bodies and for 10 years at the UoA Architecture School is all really rewarding.
My school-motto was ‘Receive the light and pass it on’ and it looks like that stayed with me!
Over the next five years, what is the single biggest change in the rules or how we work that you think our sector desperately needs?
A former Lecturer of mine used to remind us that “Building something to Code [the rules] is simply doing the legal minimum needed to avoid going to jail or breaking the law”.
If we, as a country, have legislation about controlling our emissions then it is a fair question to ask why the Code would not include something about minimum performance on that.
Whilst also acknowledging that when setting a legal-minimum, in any field, the average societal expectation will likely sit above that: legal minimums have to prevent-the-worst not encourage-the-best.
So I don’t think the Code can save us, but when it is silent on the minimum performance of something as important as a buildings effect on our fragile ecosystem then it is failing.
If the 5-years-from-now-magic-wand could introduce good clear legal-minimums for environmental performance of buildings I’d be happy. Doing it next year would be even better.
To wrap things up, what is your favourite green building here in New Zealand or anywhere else in the world?
Yikes – another hard question!! I’m going to choose to artificially constrain this just to projects I have worked on, but I have been fortunate to work on so many great projects that picking a favourite is still very tricky!
But I’m going to say: ‘The Sustainable Coastlines Flagship Centre’ down in Wynyard Quarter. Built from 85% salvaged materials, against the odds, and by a passionate rag-tag of volunteers it was unlike any other project of mine. But because its ‘mission statement’ was crystal clear and because the client made the time at the start to embed that in the project processes and people, we pulled it off. The building is currently still there – go check it out.